测父系DNA中美的report提供的信息类似吗？

[wokao]

需要比较详细的Y染色体型号信息

比如

O1b-F3323

[da1gaku]

在美国23andme测的数据可以免费上传到国内的wegene

[wokao]

在美国23andme测的数据可以免费上传到国内的wegene

貌似国内两个都提供上传

Not sure what would be more accurate, but I'll share my results. I believe my results are more divergent than yours lol.

I uploaded my 23andme results to both sites as well.

Wegene: 93.16% Southern Han, 2.91% Hmong-Mien, 1.46% Lahu

23Mofang: 63.22% Hmong, 36.78% Zhuang. LOL, I'm not Han Chinese at all according to 23mofang. Quite the shock if you ask me. Digging further this may be because I used 23andme data? I'm not sure how they can cleanly separate Southern Han from Hmong anyway. I believe 23Mofang overassigns Hmong ancestry and Wegene underassigns minority ancestry. My real background is probably somewhere in between, since it doesn't make since that I can score nearly pure Han on Wegene and nearly no minority.

In my case the difference between Wegene and 23mofang is HUGE. 23Mofang implies I'm basically a sinicized minority while Wegene shows that i am majority Southern Han haha. I definitely identify as Han Chinese while my grandparents identified as "Hakka" (subset of Han) so I'll continue doing that. I never had any familiarity with Hmong or Zhuang culture/identity. I do know Hakka people have a long history of intermarrying regional tribes which explains my high level of "minority" ancestry at least according to 23mofang.

[denizen]

Wegene: 93.16% Southern Han ~ 23Mofang: 63.22% Hmong, 36.78% Zhuang

这不是很准嘛

63.22% + 36.78%总不能刚好93.16%吧？总得有点重合吧？

差个七七八八的百分点，很正常。

就是一套班子，两块牌子。Southern Han 跟sinicized Hmong 有啥区别

倒是zhuang的父系不该算汉吗？当然如果是女的，大概率也是俩X都是南蛮了。