伪史论者最后的稻草也要沉了，黄教授这下唯一能argue的就只剩这碳14测年不是他亲自做的了。ZMZM 写了： 2025年 8月 4日 20:06 马王堆出土起码是西汉早期的可以碳十四鉴定的吧，西方类似的有吗？按说埃及的木乃伊可以鉴定，据说庞贝有人的遗骸。
当然你说的也不错，历史都是屎，尤其是古代史。其实伪史伪史的支持者和反对者大概可以按老将小将划分，所以说一切历史都是当代史
https://www.bbc.com/news/10345875
Radiocarbon dating verifies ancient Egypt's history
The Step Pyramid of Djoser in Saqqara is the oldest stone pyramid in Egypt
By Katia Moskvitch
Science reporter, BBC News
Experts have used scientific dating techniques to verify the historical chronology of ancient Egypt.
Radiocarbon dating was used to show that the chronology of Egypt's Old, Middle and New Kingdoms is indeed accurate.
The researchers dated seeds found in pharaohs' tombs, including some from the tomb of the King Tutankhamun.
They write in the journal Science that some of the samples are more than 4,500 years old.
Radiocarbon dating of ancient Egyptian objects is nothing new.
But this time, the scientists say, they were able to use a very precise statistical technique to actually verify the Egyptian history.
"The very first dating done with radiocarbon was dating Egyptian material of known dates, to check that [the method] worked," said Andrew Shortland from Cranfield University in the UK.
"Now, for the very first time, [we] managed to get radiocarbon techniques so good, that we can do it completely the opposite way around. We can say, from using radiocarbon, whether the Egyptian history is correct or not.
"Previously radiocarbon hasn't had a voice on this because the errors had been so great. Now radiocarbon is able to distinguish between different ideas of reconstructing the history."
The study brought together researchers from the UK, France, Austria and Israel.
Oxford radiocarbon accelerator
Scientists used Oxford's radiocarbon accelerator to date the items
They dated 211 various plants, seeds and papyrus samples, obtained from museum collections.
"The museums were all very helpful in providing material we were interested in—especially important since export of samples from Egypt is currently prohibited," said Christopher Ramsey, the lead author of the study, from the school of archaeology at the University of Oxford.
"Fortunately, we only needed samples that were about the same size as a grain of wheat," he added.
Thomas Higham, another member of the team who is also from the University of Oxford, explained that many items were found in ancient Egyptians' tombs and other archeological sites "where we could independently determine their historical age".
King Tut's tomb
"For example, we used seeds and plant material from Tutankhamun's tomb, which is very precisely dated. We also used seeds from a room underneath the Saqqara step pyramid dated to a specific year of the reign of King Djoser," he said.
Djoser was one of the pharaohs of the third dynasty of the Old Kingdom.
The step pyramid of Djoser in Saqqara is believed to be the oldest stone pyramid in Egypt.
Dr Ramsey's team was able to determine the exact period when this king reigned Egypt - from about 2691 to roughly 2625 BC, said the scientist.
The team found that this particular event took place earlier than some scholars previously thought.
"For the first time, radiocarbon dating has become precise enough to constrain the history of ancient Egypt to very specific dates," said Dr Ramsey.
"I think scholars and scientists will be glad to hear that our small team of researchers has independently corroborated a century of scholarship in just three years."
Seeds and papyrus from ancient Egypt
Some of the items, among them seeds and papyrus, were more than 4,000 years old
为什么这是一个错误说法？
真实情境与误解清晰对比
总结